Wiser Time does a nice job of explaining why the "COEXIST" bumper sticker shown below is basically full of crap:
You’ve seen these, right? They make me mad. Why? Because they don’t really mean what they say.This reminds me of a business card I have somewhere from a Unitarian Universalist Church that included a similar logo and said "One God, Many Paths". It makes no more sense than "COEXIST".
Let’s break it down. We’ll call each worldview by the letter it’s supposed to represent. So:
C = Islam
O = Pacifism
E = “Gender equality” (=the LGBT agenda)
X = Judaism
I = Wicca / Pagan / Bah’ai
S =Taoism / Confucianism
T = Christianity
And let’s assume a very broad definition of “coexist”: living together without calling for the destruction of each other. Here are the problems with that:
C wants to kill E, X, T, and (by implication) O. If they achieved the world they wanted, I and S would also no longer exist.
O doesn’t allow for effective resistance or defeat of C.
E stands in direct opposition to C, X, and T, and accuses those who speak against them of hate speech. Also, they’re trying to edge X and T out of public schools in favor of their own agenda. (They’re afraid C will be offended, so they get less trouble.) E is actually very, very intolerant.
X’s existence is threatened not only by C but also by O, who invariably supports C over X.
I and S are statistically insignificant and are mainly on there to complete the bumper sticker.
T is who the bumper sticker is really arguing against, but poses no physical threat to any of the others.
Historically, T has brought about more tolerance– “coexistence” if you will– than any other movement. But the kind of “coexistence” the people who make this sticker envision is one where at least X and T are completely marginalized.
My hat's off to Wiser Time for a job well done in explaining the interactions between the various entities.
And isn't it interesting that sexual identification is lumped in with religions. If they come up with a symbol for global warming that they can add to this logo they will have covered them all.
3 comments:
Love this blog post!
Roger Sharp
Time for a little parody song:
Gimme that One World Religion
Gimme that One World Religion
Gimme that One World Religion
It's good enough for me!
It was good for the New Age children
It was good for the New Age children
It was good for the New Age children
It's good enough for me.
It was good for Spock and Brothers
It was good for Spock and Brothers
It was good for Spock and Brothers
And it's good enough for me.
It will do when I am lyin'
It will do when I am lyin'
It will do when I am lyin'
It's good enough for me.
Gimme that One World Religion
Gimme that One World Religion
Gimme that One World Religion
It's good enough for me!
s/ Underdog
They could make the bumper sticker out of recyclable, renewable material, with inks made out of soybeans and adhesives made out of sugar. That would cover the global warming/environmental movement religion. Although it would wash off in the first good downpour, it would make people feel that they are 'saving the planet' for a while (which is really the important thing, isn't it)? :)
Post a Comment